Not to say this game is not without it's flaws. There are very few games that get a good enough balance of priorities for me to qualify as "perfect." However, this game comes pretty close. This is a very lengthy game, with tons of side quests that keep you going. And not the side quests that are just "bring this here, bring it back, and collect your reward." No, I'm talking about the most badass, funny, or twisted side missions you have ever seen.
However, instead of having a subject switching mess, I'll dissect this game by different subjects.
-
Gameplay:
This game has great gameplay that is built off of it's predecessor, but feels somewhat new at the same time. While I feel it's unfair to bash COD, and love this, I also feel like if every COD made it bigger, awesomer, and much better, I wouldn't be complaining as much. Very few sequels to an IP knock it out of the park this much.
The main topic of the gameplay is obviously the loot. In the first Borderlands, the loot was amazing, but soon began to be uninteresting. However, all of the guns are now colorful, interesting, easy to look at, and most of all, do shit tons of damage.
The gameplay itself is very fluid, an expectation of most Triple A games, but you'd be surprised about how many really aren't. (Any Bathesda game ever released anyone?) While the driving itself isn't anything too great, it's still an improvement over the first game. At least it's impossible to flip it over anymore, which was really frustrating in the first game.
Graphics:
This game has great graphics. I don't know why, but some people seem to think that since it doesn't look realistic, it doesn't have good graphics. Anyone who has played this game can tell that person that they're wrong. This game is fucking beautiful. The character models could be done better, and the pop-in in cut-scenes is overly obvious, but those are what seem to be tiny flaws in a beautiful world.
The guns look amazing, and each of them have their own, creative look that makes you keep it just to look at it, unless you need money. You've really out-done yourselves, Gearbox.

Replay Value
I have played this game with a mixture of solo and co-op, and both of them are equally rewarding. However, the mutliplayer is only really fun if everyone is a team player. I preferred single player because my friends are shit teammates, but it takes forever on solo, so I found myself going into co-op more and more. Especially since many things are designed for co-op in this game. Not to say that you couldn't do everything in this game on solo, but I wish you a lot of luck with that.
I currently have at least a day and a half on this game, and it came out a week ago. If that tells you anything, other than me having way too much time on my hands, is that this game is addicting and it's really hard to put it down. I'm doing a second playthrough, and it's still just as rewarding, but more difficult. The Badass System, if you try for it, can be a huge source of entertainment. It's nice to be able to upgrade all the time. You only get to upgrade your skill every now and then, so it's nice to have other ways.
There's always the achievements, and this game has great ones that are a mixture of easy and hard, but all of them are made with humor. In fact, everything is humorous in this game. Even the manual. You'll be laughing out loud at many points in the game. This is the first game to do that for me since Portal 2.
Sound:
This game has surprisingly great voice acting. The MVP of this game is definitely Handsome Jack. Half of the stuff Handsome Jack says wouldn't be as funny if it wasn't executed with the perfection it was in this game. The other voice work was awesome, but he was a standout to me.
The soundtrack itself is fairly basic, but effective. The circle of death's have ridiculously catchy music that you can't help not singing along to when you are listening to them over and over again.
Story/Writing
Let's all be honest. No one was expecting this game to have a great story. Everyone who played the first game knows that that was definitely not a strong point. In fact, it had one of the most disappointing endings in history. However, in this game, we were given not only a great story, but expertly written dialogue that makes you laugh, even if the humor is rather immature.
The ending was the same ending as the first game, pretty much, except for the part where they find out there's more vaults to hunt (future DLC!). Except, this time around, there was more at stake, and there was no stupid bitch telling you there was mounds upon mounds of loot in the vault. This game even tried to lighten up the disappointment from last game by providing an upside to last game's ending.

-
This is one of the only game I've ever played that I had high expectations for, and it not only met, them, but exceeded them in every single way. I guarantee that you'll love this game if you're a fan of co-op games, RPG's, or shooters, because this game combines them nearly flawlessly.


